A DC and her lawyer discuss a claim.

A Strong Defense Leads to a Unanimous Victory

When a patient's neurological symptoms led to a malpractice lawsuit, a chiropractor's care came under scrutiny.

When a patient developed progressive neurological symptoms following chiropractic treatment, Dr. Ron Rossey faced serious allegations that his care had caused significant spinal injuries. Defending the case successfully required sorting through conflicting accounts, complex medical evidence and questions about the patient's underlying condition.

The Situation

Tim Rae had a history of knee injuries and chronic back and neck pain. Beginning in 2011, he received intermittent chiropractic care from Ron Rossey, DC, primarily for lower back and gluteal pain. Over nearly six years, Dr. Rossey treated Tim approximately 130 times.

After an eight-month gap in care, Tim returned on August 28, 2016, reporting sharp, burning pain in his sacroiliac region. He said the symptoms were similar to pain he had experienced over the previous several years. Dr. Rossey examined and adjusted him on August 28 and August 30.

At a September 20 appointment, Dr. Rossey observed that Tim had an unsteady gait. Tim also reported numbness extending from his torso downward that had begun approximately 10 days earlier. Dr. Rossey performed a sensory examination and recommended that Tim see a neurologist.

The Allegations

Subsequent imaging and neurological evaluations revealed significant spinal abnormalities, including stenosis and changes affecting the spinal cord.

Tim initially received conservative treatment, but his symptoms progressed. In May 2017, he underwent decompression surgery and spinal fusion.

In October 2018, Dr. Rossey was served with a malpractice lawsuit alleging that he failed to recognize neurological symptoms that could contraindicate spinal manipulation and that his treatment caused Tim's injuries. The lawsuit also raised concerns about the completeness of his clinical documentation.

Building a Strong Defense

Dr. Rossey reported the lawsuit to NCMIC, which retained experienced defense counsel to represent him.

As the case developed, the defense team identified several important issues. The plaintiff's account of the treatment timeline differed from Dr. Rossey's recollection, and the clinical records did not document every examination finding. The defense also needed to address the central question of whether chiropractic treatment could have caused the spinal abnormalities identified in Tim's imaging studies.

NCMIC's claims representative took an active role in evaluating the case and working with defense counsel. When an initial assessment raised concerns about the likelihood of success at trial, NCMIC sought a second legal opinion. A new attorney reviewed the evidence and believed the case could be successfully defended.

The defense team then assembled experts with the specialties needed to address the allegations, including chiropractic, neurosurgical and neuroradiological expertise.

Their testimony became critical.

The defense challenged the connection between Dr. Rossey's adjustments and Tim's spinal injuries. A neurosurgeon explained why the patient's clinical progression was inconsistent with an acute injury caused by an adjustment. A neuroradiologist reviewed the actual imaging studies and helped the jury understand why the findings did not support the plaintiff's theory of causation.

The neuroradiologist's testimony was particularly effective in addressing weaknesses in the plaintiff's expert testimony, including the fact that the plaintiff's neurology expert had relied on imaging reports rather than reviewing the studies themselves.

Despite settlement demands as high as $1 million, the defense team believed the evidence supported taking the case to trial. Dr. Rossey agreed, and the case proceeded.

The Outcome

After six days of testimony, the jury returned a unanimous verdict in favor of Dr. Rossey, finding no liability, including on the standard-of-care allegations.

NCMIC's legal expenses to defend the case totaled $213,593.

What Can We Learn?

The right defense team matters. A case can take an unexpected turn, and a fresh perspective can make a difference. NCMIC worked with defense counsel to reassess the case, identify the right experts and develop a strategy tailored to the allegations.

Expert witnesses can make complex cases understandable. In this case, the defense's neurosurgical and neuroradiological experts helped the jury understand the patient's condition, interpret the imaging findings and evaluate whether the alleged injuries could reasonably be attributed to chiropractic treatment.

A strong defense looks beyond the allegations. Understanding the patient's history, clinical findings, imaging and subsequent treatment is essential to evaluating causation and the merits of a malpractice claim.

Good documentation still matters. Although Dr. Rossey ultimately prevailed, more detailed clinical records could have made the defense easier. Document examination findings, including negative findings, changes in symptoms, responses to treatment and the rationale for clinical decisions.

Know that your insurer is in your corner. A malpractice allegation can be stressful, but having an experienced defense team and a claims representative committed to evaluating every aspect of a case can make a meaningful difference. In this case, that commitment helped Dr. Rossey take his case to trial and secure a unanimous defense verdict.